Skip to main content

Montessori and Older Kid Discipline - Thoughts and Tips

As parents, I think we all expect the toddler and maybe even the preschool years to be full of challenging moments. We expect big feelings, impulsive behavior, and the need to set gentle but firm limits. But, I think it’s also quite common for us to expect that by elementary school a lot of these problems are behind us. These are “big” kids. These are kids that can listen, that can understand rules, and remember expectations. And sometimes we end up being really disappointed when that’s not quite reality.


This post contains affiliate links at no cost to you.

Montessori on Second Plane Kids

Let’s look at what Maria Montessori said about children in the second plane. I've taken a few quotes from a couple of books that focus on ages 6 to 12. First, here are a few of Maria's thoughts from To Educate the Human Potential:

“Whatever is presented to him must be beautiful and clear, striking his imagination. Once this love has been kindled, all problems confronting the educationist will disappear.”

"An inner change has taken place, but nature is quite logical in arousing now in the child not only a hunger for knowledge and understanding, but a claim to mental independence, a desire to distinguish good from evil by his own powers, and to resent limitation by arbitrary authority." 

“Our teaching must only answer the mental needs of the child, never dictate them. Just as a small child cannot be still because he is in need of coordinating his movements, so the older child, who may seem troublesome in his curiosity over the what, why and wherefore of everything he sees, is building up his mind by this mental activity, and must be given a wide field of culture on which to feed.“

"Here we may usefully call to our aid some myths or fairy-tales, but they must be such as symbolize truths of nature, not the wholly fantastic."

And these from her book From Childhood to Adolescence

“The child must exercise a constant watch over his own activities."

“The children become accustomed to greater challenges of a more serious and a harder form of life. While the younger child seeks comfort, the older child is now eager to encounter challenges. But these challenges must have an aim.”

"But the adults find this being, newly born to the world, a bit annoying."

So breaking this down a bit. One, second plane children can be annoying. She also at one point calls them rude. They are still little, they are still learning, and they are not mini-adults. Two, they are up for new challenges but only when they under the context of why and how. They need to know more, they want more! Three, they live for the dramatic. They need to see and feel things with their imagination.

Discipline

So, how practically does this effect our discipline as Montessori parents? We have to remember these three principles in all our interactions with second plane kids!

Expectations. First, we have to adjust our own expectations. We always need to remember to keep our expectations reasonable. We can’t expect perfection. Their job is to ask why, and how. They need to figure out social rules and how it all works. Everyone is much happier if we don’t expect perfection.

Challenges and Context. Two, we also have to remember that these kids are often ready for big work and more responsibility. But we can’t give this responsibility in isolation. We have to get buy in from this age group, they need to know why it’s important and why we are asking something of them. This context is essential for compliance. We have to remember they need the aim.

Harness their Imagination. You can’t just tell them the rules, or show them the rules, you have to get dramatic. Appeal to their imagination and tell stories. Use stories to your advantage and they are much more likely to be interested, remember, and learn.

Montessori parenting advice for older children. Here are some tips on how to approach discipline and limit setting with older children in Montessori.

Have you seen some of these shifts in your older children?

---

Comments

Popular Posts

The Ultimate Montessori Toy List -- Birth to Five -- UPDATED 2020

When you are interested in Montessori, it can be difficult to know exactly what types of products you should get for your home. Or which types of "Montessori" materials are really worth the price. There are no rules about types of products can use the name Montessori which can add to the confusion. Not to mention, every toy manufacturer slaps the word "educational" on the package for good measure! 2021 UPDATE: Please be patient with links this year, with supply chain issues things are selling out faster and restocking slower. I anticipate some of the specialty toys will not restock once they are gone. So, with this post, I'm going to try to help with this confusion! Here's a list of Montessori-friendly toys and materials for babies, toddlers and preschoolers.  First, let's clarify that there is no such thing as a "Montessori toy." Montessori never created toys, but only works for classroom settings. While there are many work

Montessori Toddler: Favorite Toys and Activities 18 to 20 months

I've been putting off this post for a little while because I felt a little disappointed that I didn't have more to share. See, Teddy just isn't that into materials, especially those on the shelf. He tends to return to a couple of favorites over and over again and ignore all other attempts at shelf work. But, really that's my own adult feelings getting in the way of Teddy's own interests, and developmental path.  It's also me subconsciously valuing fine motor skills and stillness as more important than gross motor play and movement. I working hard not to do that, and want to normalize that all toddlers are different. All children have different interests and that concentration doesn't have to mean sitting still for long stretches of time.  This post contains affiliate links at no cost to you. With all that said, here are some of Teddy's favorites over the last couple of months. Favorite Montessori Toys 18 to 20 Months I'm listing the toys that have be

Our Kids' Montessori Gift Lists 2020

With the holiday season upon us we've been making lists and gathering gifts for the Kavanaugh children. It's always a fun process of observing my children, seeing what they would really be interested in and making some decisions based on what I see. This year is different because I'm also making decisions knowing that we are looking at a very long and quiet winter ahead. So that's influencing the amount I will buy and the specific choices I will/have made.  Henry and Nora are also at the point, being into the second plane of development, where they heavily influence the items on the list and what is ultimately purchased. So, you'll see that while Montessori influences what I will purchase and what goes on their list, so does their own preferences and personality.  This post contains affiliate links at no cost to you.  Theodore Teddy is 14-months-old right now and as the fourth baby, we have so many toddler things. But, there are a few things I've still found tha